While the previous lessons have elucidated the myriad benefits of gratitude, it’s essential to approach this powerful concept and emotion with a holistic view. Gratitude can be used as one of many components of well-being, and it’s imperative to understand it in its rightful context. This lesson emphasizes the importance of authenticity in feeling gratitude and sheds light on the intricacies of the scientific studies in this domain.

1. Gratitude: A Piece of the Puzzle

• • Holistic Well-being: Total wellness is not only physical but encompasses all aspects of an individual including behavioral, emotional, social spiritual, and psychological dimensions. While gratitude can significantly impact overall well-being, other elements like nutrition, exercise, meditation, and social connections also play pivotal roles. Therefore, gratitude is a tool, not a panacea.
  • Contextual Relevance: The positive effects of gratitude may vary based on individual circumstances. For instance, someone going through severe depression or trauma might benefit from various interventions, with gratitude being just one of them.

2. Authenticity Matters

• • Sincerity: True benefits emerge when gratitude is genuine. Feigned or artificial gratitude might not only be ineffective but could also be counterproductive. A person might feel pressure or guilt for not feeling grateful, leading to added emotional distress.
  • Individual Differences: It’s crucial to recognize that everyone has their rhythm of experiencing emotions. Pressuring oneself or others to feel grateful in every situation can be disingenuous.

3. Gratitude Research: Not as Black and White

• • Designing Studies: The subjective nature of gratitude poses challenges in designing and conceptualizing studies. Quantifying such an emotion accurately requires nuanced methodologies.
  • Varied Results: Not all research on gratitude reports positive outcomes. Some studies may find negligible effects or even negative consequences, especially if gratitude is forced or becomes a source of stress.
  • Replicability Crisis: Some findings in psychological science, including those related to gratitude, have not been reproducible. This doesn’t negate the benefits of gratitude but underlines the need for robust research methodologies. This is also not unusual in scientific studies on humans. It is very difficult in human studies to isolate variables in a study.

4. When Gratitude Doesn’t Work

• • Overemphasis: Overemphasizing gratitude in situations that demand other emotional responses (like grief, anger, or sadness) can be invalidating and harmful.
  • Toxic Positivity: Gratitude should not be used to suppress or dismiss genuine negative feelings. This phenomenon, called toxic positivity, can lead to emotional repression.
  • One Size Doesn’t Fit All: Just as medicines have varied effects on individuals, gratitude interventions may not work universally. It’s essential to tailor well-being tools to individual needs.

Incorporating gratitude as part of a comprehensive approach to mental health: A Potent but Balanced Approach

Mental health is a complex interplay of biological, psychological, and social factors. In recent years, the field of psychology has expanded its lens to look beyond just symptom reduction, focusing also on holistic well-being. One practice that has received significant attention in this regard is gratitude. While it isn’t a cure-all, gratitude has emerged as a powerful tool in holistic mental health regimens.

Gratitude, simply put, is the acknowledgment of the good in life. Whether it’s appreciating a kind act, recognizing our personal strengths, or savoring nature’s beauty, gratitude has a way of focusing the mind on the positive.

As we have discussed at length, scientific studies on gratitude have shown its potential benefits, such as:

• Improved mood and reduced depressive symptoms.
• Increased life satisfaction.
• Strengthened resilience.
• Enhanced relationships.

A study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that regularly journaling about gratitude could lead to increased optimism and improved well-being. Another research in Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being noted that gratitude interventions could be especially beneficial for individuals with mental health issues.

Gratitude in Holistic Mental Health Treatment

Conventional Western medicine, also called allopathic medicine, tends to focus almost exclusively on the physical. It is only recently that there has been any emphasis on mental health and on social determinants of health. The behavioral, emotional, social, and spiritual aspects of an individual are largely not addressed. Admittedly, many of the most common issues such as headaches, belly pain, diffuse body pain, and fatigue, are known to be “stress” related issues. Regardless, we tend to treat the physical symptom with pharmaceuticals or sometimes even procedures and not treat the foundational causes, mostly because it’s easier. Newer forms of therapy such as those used in counseling or positive psychology attempt to address these issues at a more foundational level.  Here’s how gratitude fits into this paradigm:

1. Cognitive Re-framing: Negative thought patterns are common in conditions like depression and anxiety. Gratitude practices can serve as a cognitive tool to help individuals shift their focus from what’s lacking or negative to what’s abundant and positive in their lives.
2. Enhancing Mindfulness: Mindfulness is the practice of staying present. When combined with gratitude, individuals learn not only to be present but also to find moments of appreciation in the now, be it in a breath, a sound, or a memory.
3. Body and Spirit: Gratitude can lead to reduced stress levels, which has physiological benefits, such as lower blood pressure and improved immune function. Spiritually, gratitude often plays a role in grounding, providing a sense of connection to something bigger – whether it’s nature, humanity, or a higher power.

A Note of Caution

While gratitude has its merits, it’s crucial to approach it with balance:

• Gratitude isn’t a Panacea: It’s essential to remember that gratitude isn’t a replacement for comprehensive mental health treatments, such as professional counseling or medication. It’s an adjunct, another tool in the toolbox.
• The Danger of Forced Gratitude: Genuine gratitude has its benefits, but forced or feigned gratitude can be counterproductive. Individuals should never feel pressured into gratitude, especially during challenging times. I find that gratitude has to be authentic to be effective. I believe that is one issue of many that makes the research studies challenging.

Importantly, I have found that most of the time, when someone is ready to let go of a hurt or a held victim scenario, they can find something they can be grateful for within it. Often it starts with one small thing. Later it grows to bigger ones. It doesn’t happen until someone is ready. In our training, we emphasize holding onto hurts causes you pain and suffering, not the other person. You look to let it go for you, not for the one who “victimized” you. Even if you find a way to forgive them, you do it for you. We focus on this in the self-awareness portion of our program.

 

Incorporating gratitude into your life on a regular daily basis.

1. Gratitude Journaling: Setting aside a few minutes daily to write about moments or things one is grateful for can gradually shift mindset.
2. Gratitude Meditation: Combining gratitude with meditation can enhance both practices, grounding individuals in the present moment.
3. Gratitude Reminders: Using notes, alarms, or apps to sprinkle moments of gratitude throughout the day can help reinforce the practice. Finding gratitude for small, everyday, common occurrences or events.  I call these “Gratitude Bites”. These are offered in the form of daily gratitude emails or texts that I can provide if one chooses.

 

Conclusion

Gratitude, when genuine and practiced mindfully, can be a transformative emotion. However, it’s essential to understand its place in the larger wellness paradigm. It is one of many tools we possess in the pursuit of a meaningful, joyful, and healthy life. As with any tool, it’s most effective when used appropriately and in conjunction with other well-being strategies.

 

Exercise: Authentic Gratitude Journaling

Objective: This exercise is designed to help you differentiate between moments of genuine gratitude and times when gratitude might feel forced. It promotes self-awareness and a more profound understanding of your feelings.

Duration: 15-20 minutes daily for one week.

Materials: A notebook or journal, a pen.

Instructions:

1. Setting the Scene: Choose a quiet location, free from distractions. Sit comfortably and take a few deep breaths to center yourself.
2. Recalling the Day: Think about your day from the moment you woke up until the present. Recollect significant events, interactions, feelings, and thoughts.
3. Journaling:
   • Genuine Gratitude: Write down three moments or things from the day for which you felt genuine gratitude, no matter how big or small. Describe the situation and detail how it made you feel. For example, “I felt genuinely grateful when my colleague offered to help with my workload today. It made me feel supported and valued.”
   • Forced Gratitude: Reflect on any moment during the day where you felt you should be grateful but weren’t genuinely feeling it. Describe the situation and explore why you felt the gratitude might be inauthentic. For example, “I was told to feel grateful for the challenging feedback from my manager because it’s ‘for my growth,’ but I felt more hurt and unrecognized than grateful.”
4. Reflection: After journaling, take a few minutes to read your entries. Reflect on the differences between genuine and forced gratitude. How do they impact your well-being, mood, and perception of events?
5. Consistency: Repeat this exercise daily for a week.

Follow-up:

At the end of the week, review your journal entries. Look for patterns in your experiences. This review will provide insights into situations that naturally elicit gratitude and those where gratitude feels imposed. It’s a way of understanding your emotional responses better and promotes self-awareness.

Essential Tip: Remember, there’s no judgment in this exercise. It’s a personal tool to help you understand your relationship with gratitude. It’s perfectly okay not to feel grateful all the time; the aim is to recognize and appreciate authentic moments of gratitude in your life.

 

Quiz: Authentic Gratitude

1. Which of the following describes the best approach to gratitude? a) Feeling grateful in every situation, no matter what. b) Expressing gratitude only when it feels genuine. c) Using gratitude to suppress negative emotions. d) Making others always express gratitude.

Answer: b) Expressing gratitude only when it feels genuine.

1. In which situation is emphasizing gratitude likely harmful? a) Celebrating a birthday. b) Grieving a loss. c) Enjoying a meal. d) Spending time with loved ones.

Answer: b) Grieving a loss.

1. What challenge is common in designing scientific studies on gratitude? a) The emotion is easily quantifiable. b) Gratitude is universally experienced the same way. c) The subjective nature of gratitude. d) Everyone shows gratitude outwardly.

Answer: c) The subjective nature of gratitude.

References:

1. Emmons, R. A., & McCullough, M. E. (2003). Counting blessings versus burdens: An experimental investigation of gratitude and subjective well-being in daily life. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84(2), 377.
2. Watkins, P. C., Woodward, K., Stone, T., & Kolts, R. L. (2003). Gratitude and happiness: Development of a measure of gratitude and relationships with subjective well-being. Social Behavior and Personality: an international journal, 31(5), 431-452.
3. Fredrickson, B. L. (2001). The role of positive emotions in positive psychology: The broaden-and-build theory of positive emotions. American psychologist, 56(3), 218.
4. Tugade, M. M., & Fredrickson, B. L. (2004). Resilient individuals use positive emotions to bounce back from negative emotional experiences. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 86(2), 320.
5. Burton, C. M., & King, L. A. (2004). The health benefits of writing about intensely positive experiences. Journal of Research in Personality, 38(2), 150-163.
6. Neff, K. D. (2011). Self‐compassion, self‐esteem, and well‐being. Social and personality psychology compass, 5(1), 1-12. (This provides insights on the dangers of toxic positivity.)

Remember, these exercises, quizzes, and references are tools to enhance your understanding and are not definitive answers to the vast, intricate world of gratitude and positive psychology.

 

Back to: GratitudeGainz